Billing & Claims American Modern Phone: 1-800-543-2644Claims: 1-800-375-2075 Online Claims Online Payment Battle Creek Mutual Phone: 1-800-289-5401Claims: 1-855-682-6767 Online Claims Online Payment Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Phone: 1-877-680-2442Claims: 1-800-356-5750 Online Claims Online Payment Continental Western Group Phone: 1-800-235-2942Claims: 1-877-631-0354 Online Claims Online Payment Dairyland Insurance Phone: 1-800-334-0090Claims: 1-800-334-0090 Online Claims Online Payment EMC Insurance Phone: 1-800-447-2295Claims: 1-888-362-2255 Online Claims Online Payment Farmers Mutual of Nebraska Phone: 1-800-742-7433Claims: 1-800-742-7433 Online Claims Online Payment Foremost Phone: 1-888-383-4244Claims: 1-800-527-3907 Online Claims Online Payment Grinnell Mutual Phone: 1-800-362-2041Claims: 1-877-467-2252 Online Claims Online Payment Hagerty Phone: 1-877-922-9701Claims: 1-800-385-0274 Online Claims Online Payment Markel Insurance Phone: 1-888-642-4968Claims: 1-800-362-7535 Online Claims Online Payment Nationwide Phone: 1-877-669-6877Claims: 1-877-669-6877 Online Claims Online Payment NAU Country Phone: 1-866-942-6724Claims: 1-866-942-6724 Online Claims Online Payment North Star Mutual Phone: 1-800-622-5230Claims: 1-800-622-5230 Online Claims Online Payment Progressive Phone: 1-866-407-4844Claims: 1-800-776-4737 Online Claims Online Payment SFM Mutual Insurance Phone: 1-800-937-1181Claims: 1-855-675-3501 Online Claims Online Payment United Fire Group Insurance Phone: 1-800-637-6309Claims: 1-800-343-9131 Online Claims Online Payment